Updated December 1st, 2017
The purpose of this article to answer a frequently asked question (FAQ) from prospecting clients, which is “What outboard motor should I choose for my S4 skiff?”
The answer is that the outboard motor and propeller you should choose for your S4 depend mainly on two factors, which are
- How much power you need: How fast you want to go, in what kind of water, and how many passengers you’ll have on board
- How important to you is the motor’s weight.
There is a trade-off between power and weight, namely that the more powerful the motor, the heavier it is, and the harder it is to carry it.
In any case, the motor should be a 20″ log shaft (L) model, and not a 15″ short shaft (S) model.
Recommended reading: How to measure an outboard motor’s propeller shaft length? »
Another trade-off that you should know about is related to propellers: High pitch propellers are designed to deliver less torque (push force) and more speed, and they work best with lightweight boats, while low pitch propellers are designed to move bigger and heavier boats, but they should not be used with lightweight boats, since they can make the motor go at a too high RPM.
Outboard motors manufacturers’ websites say that (quote) “UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHOULD YOU EVER USE A PROP WHICH WILL ALLOW YOUR OUTBOARD TO OPERATE ABOVE THE OUTBOARD’S RECOMMENDED MAXIMUM RPMs”.
Propeller pitch information is available on outboard manufacturers’ websites.
Practically, this means that since the S4 is an extremely lightweight boat, you should outfit the outboard motor for your S4 with the highest pitch propeller available for it.
Diameter – Don’t try to use a propeller from a small outboard with a bigger outboard.
For the S4, small size means a highly portable but under-powered outboard motor.
2 HP outboards
Outboard motors in this class weigh around 30 lbs, which makes them fully portable even for a user who’s not very strong. A 2 HP motor can propel an S4 skiff with one person on board at speeds up 8 mph, even in choppy water. This speed would decrease as the boat is required to carry more passengers on board. S4 owners who tested such motors with their S4 skiff reported that the boat felt under powered, which means that they felt like going faster, but the motor lacked the power required for this. For this reason 2 HP motors are not popular with S4 users. Another reason for their lack of popularity is the fact that being air cooled makes these small motors noisier than bigger, water cooled motors.
Propeller pitch –
The Honda 2.3 HP comes with a 4.75 pitch propeller
MEDIUM SIZE OUTBOARDS
For the S4, a medium size outboard motor means powerful enough but still portable. Motors in this 3.5 HP to 6 HP range are the ones we recommend for most users.
3.5 HP outboards
Outboard motors in this range weigh around 40 lbs, which makes them still portable, but less so than 2 HP motors. A 3.5 HP motor can propel an S4 skiff with one person on board at speeds up to 11 mph, even in choppy water, and it can propel the boat at 8 mph with three passengers on board in moving water. This size motor is popular among S4 and W700 users, as it offers a good trade-off between power and weight for people who must lift the motor or carry it by hand over long distances.
These motors are also less expensive than bigger ones.
Propeller pitch –
For their 3.5 HP motor, Tohatsu recommends either the 7 pitch (Plastic) or 6 pitch (aluminum) propellers, for lightweight boats such as the S4.
We say get the 7 pitch, unless you think that you need the more durable aluminum propeller.
6 HP outboards
Outboard motors in this range weigh around 60 lbs, which makes them portable only over short distances, and not for everyone.
A 6 HP motor can propel an S4 skiff with one person on board at speeds of up to 18 mph, and it can propel the boat at 13 mph with three passengers on board.
6 HP motors are the second most popular motors among S4 users.
For their 6 HP outboard used with lightweight boats (such as the S4), Tohatsu recommends their 9 pitch propeller.
8 HP to 10 HP outboard motors are too heavy to be carried by hand, and they may be too powerful for inexperienced drivers to use safely. However, they come with electric start instead on manual start, which is a nice feature. They also come with an alternator that can serve to power small electric devices.
8 HP outboards
Outboard motors in this class weigh around 80 lbs. At such weight, these motors can no longer be considered as portable, and the main reason to use them is the fact that are offered with electric ignition, which eliminates the need to start them by pulling a cord. People who like driving at high speed may prefer these motors to less powerful ones. The S4 outfitted with an 8 HP motor performs well in choppy water, but it could feel over powered for an inexperienced driver, which should avoid using such motors with their S4. Heavy users may benefit from driving with a U-jointed tiller extension, in order to move some weight forward from the stern towards the middle of the boat.
Note that these bigger motors don’t come with an integrated fuel tank, but this isn’t necessarily a problem, since external fuel tanks can fit inside the S4’s hulls.
9.9 HP outboards
We tested the S4 with a 9.9 HP Yamaha outboard, and it worked well. Practically, this class of heavier and more powerful motors offers no advantage over smaller motors unless you feel you must go at high speeds, and you’re capable of driving small boats safely at such speeds.
We recommend that inexperienced drivers avoid using high power motors. Instead, they should pick a motor within the 3.5 HP to 6 HP range.
Mud motors feature a surface drive, and they offer a huge advantage to people who want to drive in very shallow water, mud, water with many underwater obstacles, and water with plenty of vegetation.
6.5 HP mud motors
Mud motors are bulkier and heavier than regular outboard motors. A 6.5 HP mud motor weighs around 80 lbs, and it’s not portable. The reasons you’d want to use such a motor instead of a regular outboard of similar power are if you need to go in very shallow water (skinny water) and mud, and if you fish or hunt in water with plenty of vegetation and underwater obstacles. The S4 performs very well with a such a mud motor. We do not recommend using less powerful mud motors because typically, these motors require more power than regular outboard motors do.
Electric outboard motors
Some electric trolling motors are described by their manufacturer as “outboard motors”, namely comparable in power to small outboard gas engines. If you consider such electric motors, we recommend remembering the laws of physics, and applying the formulae for Kilowatts to Horsepower conversion, which are:
- 1 KW = 1.34 HP
- 1 HP = 0.745 KW
No amount of words may overcome this reality.
Electric motors are discussed in the Electric Trolling Motor or Outboard Gas Engine section of this article »